Center for Citizen Media Rotating Header Image

Bragging Rites

  • SF Chronicle: Chronicle gets array of national honors. The Chronicle staff won more than two dozen national awards in a slew of prestigious contests, including a strong showing in an international “Picture of the Year” competition.
  • Mercury News: Mercury News Honored. The San Jose Mercury News received top recognition for photography and design in two prestigious international competitions.


Does a newspaper ever win an award that isn’t prestigious?

No business pats itself on the back more assiduously than journalism, with the possible exception of entertainment.

Business Blogging Junket

Evidence of a blogging business bubble?

Citizen Journalists and a Greedy Telecom Company's Policy

Tom Evslin: AT&T is Ripping Off American Soldiers. It’s bad enough that they overcharge domestic customers but we have alternatives. The soldiers don’t because, according to The Prepaid Press, AT&T has an EXCLUSIVE contract to put payphones in PXes in Iraq and Afghanistan. But, you ask, can’t the soldiers get cheap calling cards to call the US? No! Because AT&T is using (abusing!) its position as monopoly supplier of payphones to block the 800 numbers necessary to use nonAT&T calling cards.

See Tom’s follow-up posts as well (here, here).

He points out that this greedy — but, it seems, entirely legal — stance was instituted prior to SBC’s buyout of the company. I suspect that the plan was to continue it, but also suspect the revelation of this abuse will force the company to modify its policy. (Tom wonders if the new management even knows about the situation, but if it didn’t surface during pre-purchase due diligence someone senior should be fired.)

I’ve had my own trouble lately with AT&T, but it’s small potatoes next to this poor treatment of men and women who a) are putting their lives on the line every day and b) have no alternative. (I had alternatives when AT&T put me through a wringer in my ultimately unsuccessful attempt to add minutes to my phone card, and I took one.)

Big Media has all but ignored the AT&T Iraq phone card story. Here’s a CNN report about a story in the Newark Star Ledger from a year ago; I can’t find the original online. This looks like a story that got barely noticed, and then ignored. Why? I doubt it’s because AT&T is such a major advertiser. More likely, reporters and editors say to themselves, “Well, the Star Ledger has already written the story. It’s old news.”

It’s not old news when the overcharging continues. And in the way the Web can have of elevating important news, a posting on the O’Reilly Emerging Telephony site, pointing to Evlin’s posting, got “Digged” in a major way. Jeff Jarvis and other prominent bloggers have linked to it as well. I predict it’ll be back in the Big Media very soon now.

Tom notes that this issue seems to have originated, in any event, with an publication called the Prepaid Press, which sells newsletters and runs an online site as well. In an update, the publication’s Gene Retske notes that the American Legion is taking up the soldiers’ cause. Good for the Legion, good for Retske and Evslin; the latter two are using citizen journalism to stir up the right kind of trouble.

BBC Media Column Debuts

I’ve started a column for BBC News — this one is the first, an introduction to what citizen media is all about and why I think it’s important. The piece has drawn lots of responses on the BBC’s “Have Your Say” forum, and I’ll be responding online to some of the questions and comments.

One More Reason Newspapers are Losing Readers: Cowardice

Editor & Publisher: South Dakota’s Top Paper Refuses To Editorialize On Abortion Ban. “Part of it was that we wouldn’t change people’s minds, and part of it, regardless of which side we came down on this, is that people would read into it things that are not true,” Chuck Baldwin, editorial page editor of the Argus Leader in Sioux Falls, S.D., told E&P. “People would think our coverage is tainted, and not just on abortion but on everything.”

We can argue about whether the concept of an editorial page is outmoded, but as long as editorial pages exist they have a nearly absolute obligation to talk with their communities about the big issues of the day, and to take stands. This decision — this refusal to engage in a core function of a newspaper — is cowardly.

Writely Goes to Google

Anyone under illusions that Google isn’t aiming at Microsoft, though mostly from the side rather than directly into Microsoft’s strength, should note that the search and advertising company just bought Writely, a Web-based word processor that is one of the coolest apps around. It lets people edit together and see each others’ revisions in an elegant way.

Looking forward to seeing what Google does this this application, which has some obvious implications for citizen journalism.

On the Road

I’m in Buenos Aires for a talk tomorrow at a gathering sponsored by Clarin, the biggest media outfit in the region. The company just made big changes to its website, which is celebrating its 10th anniversary. (Note: The company has paid for my trip.)

Enjoyed a very long lunch today with some folks from the news operation plus several other speakers. We ate steak, needless to say here, and I learned that one of the big current stories is that Argentina has suspended beef exports. Apparently lots of land that had been used for cattle is now going for soybean production, I was told, and beef prices are soaring.

I don’t eat a lot of red meat, but I’ll continue to make an exception on this brief visit.

Citizen Media Talk Next Week at Harvard

I’m giving a talk next week at Harvard Law School entitled: “Engaging with the News, Part I: The Daily Me and We,” part of a series of talks this winter and spring.

When: Tuesday, March 14, 7 pm
Where: Pound 102, Harvard Law School

Here’s the blurb the Berkman Center for Internet & Society is sending out and posting.

In a world of democratized media, we don’t have to settle anymore for the newspaper that a carrier drops in the driveway or the 5 o’clock news broadcast. Even the traditional media are offering new choices, including podcasts and outbound links, but this is only a starting point. We can, and should, assemble our own news reports from the vast data streams. We can use tools to help navigate our way through the masses of information, but the human component remains crucial. Recommendation systems and other emergent notions can help answer the question of who and what is trustworthy in a world where anyone can publish.

Dan Gillmor is the founder & director of CitizenMedia.org, author of “We the Media,” and a Berkman Center fellow. This event is the second in a series of public talks on citizens media. Drinks & desserts will be provided!

Questions? Want to get involved in citizen media research? Contact the Berkman Center, 617-495-7547 or reply to this email.

Again, the time and location: Tuesday, March 14, 7 pm at Pound 102, Harvard Law School.

Hope to see some of you.

Beyond Broadcast Conference May 12-13

This center is co-hosting a gathering this May called “Beyond Broadcast: Reinventing Public Media in a Participatory Culture,” to be held at Harvard Law School. Check out the conference wiki for more information.

Taking it Back? Hard to Do in Google's World

Reuters: Google lets slip talk of online storage service: Google Inc. is preparing to offer online storage to Web users, creating a mirror image of data stored on consumer hard drives, according to company documents that were mistakenly released on the Web. The existence of the previously rumored GDrive online storage service surfaced after a blogger discovered apparent notes in a slide presentation by Google executives published on Google’s site after its analysts presentation day last Thursday.

I have my doubts that Google truly didn’t want this information out in the wild. The company showed the slides in question to analysts, after all, so there was no real secret.

The most interesting part of this story is what happened to the information, plus some of the Keystone Kops moves the company made along the way. Blogger Greg Linden found slides online with details. Google pulled the slides off its website and put up a PDF, minus some key materials. Commenters on Linden’s blog relocated and posted the missing material.

Then, Linden and others noticed that notes from the slides contained other material Google a) didn’t mean to put out because b) it contained outdated revenue and profit projections (Reuters). Yike…

Lessons? Among them: It’s hard to keep secrets if you put things on the Web.

And this from Linden, who gets the last word: “Google’s mission may be ‘to organize the world’s information and make it universally accessible,’ but some information is not intended to be accessed by all.”