Center for Citizen Media Rotating Header Image

"Human-powered Search" Paying Humans

Jason Calacanis, who calls his new venture Mahalo “human-powered search,” says the company will pay freelance searchers a fee for links the site accepts. He says he hopes for hundreds or thousands of people in this part-time capacity.

This sounds to me like an updated version of the Open Directory Project, but this time with payments for the editors. Not a bad idea.

seo012.jpgIn his talk at the NMK event, Jason called for wide efforts to rid the Net of the pollution he says threatens to choke off all of the value. He had particular contempt for the search engine “optimization” industry that he believes is one of the worst polluters. (Click on his slide, left, to see a trajectory of decline.)

blogs013.jpg

But, he says, blogs have so far responded fairly well with antibodies. (The “blogs” slide at right has a happier ending.) Naturally, he pitches his new company as an andidote for part of the problem.

There’s no question that the major Internet companies (read Google, Yahoo, Microsoft et al) have not done enough to curb the pollution. But do we really want to toss out the part of this that machines handle so well? I don’t think so.

3 Comments on “"Human-powered Search" Paying Humans”

  1. #1 Mahalo and human-powered search at Ghost of Midnight
    on Jun 13th, 2007 at 1:58 pm

    […] Dan Gillmor wrote recently… Jason Calacanis, who calls his new venture Mahalo “human-powered search,” says the company will pay freelance searchers a fee for links the site accepts. He says he hopes for hundreds or thousands of people in this part-time capacity. […]

  2. #2 tercüme
    on Jun 14th, 2007 at 3:20 am

    There’s no question that the major Internet companies (read Google, Yahoo, Microsoft et al) have not done enough to curb the pollution

  3. #3 Phil Gomes
    on Jun 15th, 2007 at 6:49 am

    SEO firms pitch their businesses to me all the time.

    About two years ago, one guy kept me on the phone FOREVER. While he was talking, I quietly did a search for “search engine optimization” in Google.

    I had gotten to page 27 and still hadn’t found the name of his company. I challenged him on it.

    “Well,” the guy said. “This is a *very* crowded space.”

    “Well,” I responded. “Do you know that one of our clients sells BEANS and another one sells DEODORANT!?”

    (Talk about crowded.)